Interpretation that Zhuge Liang's Northern Expeditions were for the purpose of maintaining power
Yes. In fact, the Three Kingdoms period can be interpreted from that perspective. However, the academic community does not simply conclude that Zhuge Liang's Northern Expeditions were wars intended solely to maintain the power of the foreign forces that entered following Liu Bei.
The issue you raised is quite important for understanding the political structure of the Three Kingdoms.
The core lies in the power structure within Shu Han.
The Liu Bei faction was not a local force that had been rooted in Yizhou from the beginning.
Liu Bei led the forces active in Jing Province and seized control of Yizhou in 214. Subsequently, the ruling class of Shu Han was divided into roughly the following political bases:
* Jing Province Faction: Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhuge Liang, and those around them who followed Liu Bei
* Yizhou Faction: Local gentry and officials who had established bases in the region since the era of Liu Zhang
* Eastern Province Faction: External officials and military forces who had been active in Yizhou since the time of Liu Zhang
Looking at Zhuge Liang's Northern Expeditions through this framework, one can consider political meanings beyond a simple conquest of the Wei Kingdom.
### 1. There is an academic interpretation very close to your hypothesis
Interestingly, a study published in a 2026 Taiwan National University political science journal presents an argument quite similar to your perspective.
The title of the paper is *No Coexistence with the Usurper, No Peace under Fragmented Rule?*
The core arguments of this study are as follows:
* Shu Han was a regime established by the Liu Bei faction, which entered from the outside, seizing control of the local Yizhou.
* Political competition existed between the local indigenous forces and the foreign ruling class.
* The Liu Bei faction, as the foreign ruling class, needed a strong justification to legitimize their rule.
* That justification was the grand cause of inheriting the legitimacy of the Han Dynasty and reviving the Han Dynasty.
* Therefore, the Northern Expeditions served not only for territorial expansion but also to maintain the legitimacy of the regime and internal cohesion.
In other words, this study interprets the Northern Expeditions of Shu Han not merely as a military strategy, but as a strategy to maintain the political legitimacy of the ruling coalition. politics.ntu.edu.tw +1
This is a study that directly touches upon the hypothesis you mentioned.
### 2. For Zhuge Liang, the Northern Expeditions were also a matter of internal politics
From this perspective, it is necessary to examine several historical circumstances.
① Instability of the power base after Liu Bei's death
After Liu Bei died in 223, Zhuge Liang effectively became the highest authority in Shu Han.
However, Zhuge Liang was neither a relative of Liu Bei nor a member of the local Yizhou forces. He was a figure who had been active with Liu Bei in Jing Province before entering Yizhou.
Therefore, the Shu Han regime he ruled required not only political legitimacy but also the cooperation of internal forces.
② The Northern Expeditions created a common goal for the regime.
When Zhuge Liang pursued the Northern Expeditions, the political goals of the officials and soldiers from Jing Province were maintained.
On the other hand, from the perspective of the local Yizhou forces, they might have questioned the reason for fighting a war against the Wei Kingdom while bearing the burden of massive manpower and finances.
In fact, after Zhuge Liang's death, the difference in policy stances regarding the Northern Expeditions became even more apparent.
A 2022 study from the University of Hong Kong also analyzes that while various political forces were temporarily united through the Northern Expeditions during Zhuge Liang's leadership, conflicts between internal political factions resurfaced after his death. HKU Scholars Hub +1
### 3. The situation after Zhuge Liang's death serves as evidence supporting this hypothesis
An interesting change appears when looking at the flow after Zhuge Liang's death in 234.
| Figure | Political/Military Characteristics |
| --- | -------------------- |
| Zhuge Liang | Actively pursued Northern Expeditions |
| Zhang Wan | Adjusted the scale and direction of Northern Expeditions |
| Fei Yi | Cautious stance on large-scale Northern Expeditions |
| Jiang Wei | Resumed active pursuit of Northern Expeditions |
| Qiao Zhou | Opposed Northern Expeditions, advocated for surrender to Wei |
In particular, Qiao Zhou, who is evaluated as a figure representing the interests of the local Yizhou forces, opposed Jiang Wei's Northern Expeditions.
Qiao Zhou's work, 《Treatise on the Enemy State (仇國論)》, contains the logic that focus should be placed on internal stability rather than continuous warfare with the Wei Kingdom.
A 2024 paper by Professor Zhu Jiayan of Shanghai University also divides the interior of Shu Han into three political groups—the Jing Province faction, the Eastern Province faction, and the local Yizhou faction—and analyzes the impact of their political interests on the policies and downfall of Shu Han. journal.ujn.edu.cn +1
However, caution is needed not to understand these divisions as modern-day political parties or organized factions.
### 4. Then, did Zhuge Liang conduct the Northern Expeditions to maintain power?
Here, it is necessary to distinguish between three motivations:
* National Justification: The goal of inheriting the legitimacy of the Han Dynasty and unifying the world.
* Military Strategy: A strategy to continuously apply military pressure before the Wei Kingdom could acquire overwhelming national strength.
* Political Purpose: The purpose of maintaining the legitimacy of the foreign ruling class and uniting the ruling coalition, such as the Jing Province and Eastern Province factions.
These three are not mutually exclusive motivations.
Especially from Zhuge Liang's perspective, giving up the Northern Expeditions might not have been simply a matter of changing military strategy. It was because there was a risk of weakening even the national justification for why Shu Han should exist.
### I think the most interesting question is this.
If Zhuge Liang had stopped the Northern Expeditions and focused on internal administration and economic development centered on Yizhou, could the Jing Province faction that followed Liu Bei have continued to hold power in Shu Han?
This is a very important counterfactual question for viewing the history of Shu Han.
If the Northern Expeditions were not just an external war but a means to maintain the political cohesion of the internal ruling class, then for Zhuge Liang, stopping the Northern Expeditions might have meant more than a military retreat; it could have meant the weakening of the influence of the political forces he led.
When examining the perspective you asked about, I believe it is important not only to look at Zhuge Liang's personal loyalty or military ability but also to examine the question of who ruled Shu Han and who cooperated with that rule after Liu Bei occupied Yizhou.
Comments 0