Are there any highly acclaimed games that just didn't click with you?

For me, RDR2 and The Witcher 3 were underwhelming.
I was so excited for RDR2 when it launched that I pre-ordered it, but once I actually played it, it was so boring that I sold the CD after only 4 hours.
I guess your preferred genre is really important when it comes to games.
No matter how great a game is, if it's not a genre I like, it's just not that great...