Romance of the Three Kingdoms) If Lu Xun had replaced Zhou Yu, would the Battle of Red Cliffs have been won?

‌
If Zhou Yu had not commanded the Battle of Red Cliffs and Lu Xun had instead, would Lu Xun have led Red Cliffs to victory?
And if Zhou Yu had commanded the Battle of Yiling instead of Lu Xun, would he have won?
I am assuming they are both in their prime, despite the difference in their eras and ages.