A legendary shooting guard who had less impact than expected

Reggie Miller

5-time All-Star
3-time All-NBA Third Team
These are his only major accolades
Career stats are 18.2-3.0-3.0
Aside from his signature off-ball scoring, he didn't have any standout skills, and while his defense wasn't a liability, at best he was just average
Of course, playing 18 seasons for one team, he left behind countless clutch shots and highlights, and even made it to the Finals
However, his limitations as a primary option were clear; he only approached championship contention after being paired with players like Jermaine O'Neal and Ron Artest (and after Jordan had already retired)